Jan De Vries is also an Economic Historian, his journal article was written much later inbut also published in the Journal of Economic History. He believes that if the government is going to make such a prohibition legal then it must be enforced unevenly or else the government plans to make criminals out of conservative parents who do their best to bring their children up right.
Carole Jenny refuted his article with an article of her own entitled Spanking Should Not Be Lawful, expressing how she firmly believes that spanking should be declared illegal in order to stop child abuse.
Though both doctors have their disagreements, they both stand on the common ground of making a change in the homes that endanger children. Fritz makes a conscious effort to describe these actions as performed non-abusive and controlled. Finally the last section of the article Hartwell then returns again to concentrate on the debate about the Industrial Revolution and how it will continue but change with the times.
As the title of this article suggest Hartwell sets out to give the reader the interpretations of the Industrial Revolution from all angles. Tell us what you need to have done now! Jenny hopes to further the United States movement to stop the abuse of children.
This convention was held to propose a prohibition against the physical punishment. On one side stand the conservative psychologists, doctors, and parents who believe that a good smack on the buttocks is appropriate in guiding children and parents have the right to family privacy.
Fritz believes that there is an alternative to making criminals out of parents and hopes to educate them in alternative ways of rearing children. They both refer to the United Nations convention but show no real research on the actual convention, and Dr.
Hartwell continues by saying how some historians believed the industrial revolution was to blame for a decline in morals but Hartwell suggests there is no evidence to prove this.
On this end of the spectrum, Dr.
In the Second section, Hartwell continues by discussing how different historians choose to look at the Industrial Revolution from different perspectives, and that their own beliefs and opinions can bias their interpretation that then can bias what is written.
In the beginning of his article, Dr. Hartwell wrote this journal article init was published in the Journal of Economical History. Jenny continues the example by stating one-hundred countries adopted the law against physical punishment of children in school, while twenty-three countries went as far as to ban corporal punishment in any context.
Though both doctors disagree on what defines the abuse of a child, they both concur that child abuse is generally the major association for some child psychological outcomes such as depression, altruism, and antisocial behavior. Fritz believes that one problem that stands with most scholarly studies about child abuse is that they are biased in the sense that they label the effects of abusive spanking under the effects of controlled, non-abusive spanking, giving the effect that spanking cannot be anything but abusive.
Hartwell goes on to say that for every opinion about the Industrial Revolution there will be a counter opinion, and that because the Industrial Revolution affected a whole society no two opinions will be the same.
Additionally throughout his article, Dr. Hartwell believes that the writer will always be influenced by his own opinion and that there will always be debate in history, and the survival of history itself depends on these different views. They are both respected doctors who have both published many articles pertaining to their study.
By passing such a law, Dr. Scholarly Article Comparison According to the text of the scholarly articles, comparisons show they are all exceptionally similar when discussing each of the authors’ views of urban cities as well as their surrounding environments.
However; they also have strikingly different opinions as well. In most cases, you'll want to use articles from scholarly journals to support your arguments because these are written by experts, include references you can consult, and have been carefully edited.
Sometimes, depending on your topic, you'll need to use articles from popular magazines. What’s the Difference. Between Scholarly Journals.
and. Popular Magazines?
Who wrote the article? Scholarly • Signed by the author • Written by scholar or expert • Provides author’s credentials and affiliations • May have multiple authors. Popular • Most articles are unsigned. Comparison and contrast of two, scholarly articles with opposing viewpoints TOPIC: • Write a comparison and contrast essay in which you compare and contrast the opposing viewpoints in two scholarly articles.
Students will choose two, scholarly articles from specific, college databases.
How to Write a Comparative Analysis Throughout your academic career, you'll be asked to write papers in which you compare and contrast two things: two texts, two theories, two historical figures, two scientific processes, and so on. Internet Articles Written in the Compare and Contrast Format.